Property Management Help

Rank 3 of 21 Athens property managers

Athens Property Management Team LLC

103 E Meadow Dr, Athens, GA 30605(706) 850-6500
  • Online owner portal
  • Fees listed online
  • Owner guarantees
  • Live rental listings
4.7★Google rating89 reviews
1.0★from owner reviews1 owner review in the past 24 months
2019in business sinceCompany website
98%of reviews answeredIn its newest 50 reviews, back to May 2024

Overview

Athens Property Management Team publishes its fees: 10% of rent, charged only on rents collected, 50% of one month's rent to lease, and $75 renewals. It holds 4.7 stars from 89 Google reviews and replied to 98% of recent reviews.

Strengths

  • Full fee schedule published; management fee charged only on rents collected
  • Owner funds paid from the 10th, then daily distributions after
  • Offers a Satisfaction Guarantee and a Leasing Guarantee
  • Owner and tenant portals; listings syndicated to 50+ platforms

Where it lost points

  • Only 1 owner review in the past 24 months, rated 1 star
  • No credentials shown on its website
  • No Facebook rating found, so half credit there

Google rating over time

↓ 4%last 6 months vs overall

4.0★4.2★4.4★4.6★4.8★5.0★4.7★ overall (89)4.5★ 6 mo (17)

What owners say

1 owner review in the past 24 months · 1.0★ average

There was 1 owner review in the past 24 months. It gave 1 star and said the company works well for tenants but poorly for owners. With only one owner review, it's hard to tell whether this view is common.

What tenants say

Service complaints in 2 of its newest 50 reviews, back to May 2024

Tenants wrote 31 reviews, and service complaints showed up in 2 of 50 recent reviews (newest 50, back to May 2024). One described a water line repair that took weeks. The other disputed extra deposit charges, which is common for any manager and not counted against them.

Service area

Towns listed on Athens Property Management Team LLC’s website. The map places the ones we could find, and dots are approximate town centers. The list has every town they name.

Service area of Athens Property Management Team LLCMap of 10 towns that Athens Property Management Team LLC lists as its service area, with its office in Athens: Athens, Watkinsville, Bogart, Colbert, Jefferson, Statham, Winder, Monroe, Loganville, Madison.AthensWatkinsvilleColbertJeffersonStathamWinderMonroeLoganvilleMadison

OfficeTown they serve

  • Athens
  • Watkinsville
  • Bogart
  • Colbert
  • Jefferson
  • Statham
  • Winder
  • Monroe
  • Loganville
  • Madison

Score breakdown

74.9 of 100 points, which converts to 7.7 out of 10. Every company is scored the same way. How the formula works.

Reputation

40.9 / 59
Google rating, past 6 months
4.53 stars across 17 reviews (past 6 months)
13.8 / 18
Google rating trend (last 6 months)
4.5★ from 17 reviews vs 4.7★ overall. Shown for context; the recent rating above is what the score counts.
↓ 4%
not scored
Overall Google rating (volume-adjusted)
4.7 stars from 89 reviews → 4.55 after volume adjustment
10.1 / 13
Number of Google reviews
89 Google reviews (full credit at 250)
7.3 / 9
What owners say
1.00 stars across 1 review written by owners in the past 24 months (few owner reviews, so the score leans toward the middle)
2.8 / 11
Replies to reviews
replied to 98% of its newest 50 reviews, back to May 2024 (full credit at 80%)
6.0 / 6
Facebook rating
no Facebook rating found (half credit)
1.0 / 2

Track record

8.0 / 15
Years in business
since 2019 (website) – 7 years (full credit at 10+) Source: athensrealtyplus.com/owner-faq
8.0 / 12
Credentials
no credentials shown
0.0 / 3

Transparency

16.0 / 16
Fees published
Management fee is 10% of rent (the flyer says from 8%, charged only on rents collected). Lease fee is 50% of one month's rent, and the lease renewal fee is $75. A $500 per property maintenance reserve is held in trust. Source: athensrealtyplus.com/pricing
8.0 / 8
Guarantees published
Satisfaction Guarantee, Leasing Guarantee Source: athensrealtyplus.com
4.0 / 4
Performance stats published
At least 35% of tenants have pets (as of April 2024); No BBB complaints in company history; At least 35% of tenants have pets (April 2024) Source: athensrealtyplus.com/owner-faq Source: athensrealtyplus.com/about
2.0 / 2
Property types listed
single-family homes, HOAs, commercial, apartments / multifamily
1.0 / 1
Who runs it named
names who runs it: Michelle Thomas, Broker/Owner Source: athensrealtyplus.com/about
1.0 / 1

Owner & tenant tools

10.0 / 10
Owner portal
owner portal found Source: athensrealtyplus.com
4.0 / 4
Tenant portal
2.0 / 2
Live rental listings
live rental listings, on a separate site run by AppFolio Source: athenspropertymgmt.appfolio.com/listings
4.0 / 4

Coming next: estimated days to rent (how long a company's listed homes take to come off the market). We'll add it to every score once we have enough weeks of listing data to measure it fairly for every company.

Ratings and review counts from Google Business Profile, Nov 2, 2026 · Fees, founding year and leadership from the company’s website · Reviewed by Landon Murie

PropertyManagementHelp.com is an independent project by Landon Murie, who also owns a marketing agency that works with some property management companies. Those companies are scored with the same published formula as everyone else, and no company can pay to be listed or to change its score. Spot something wrong? Tell us and we will check it.